Skip to main content

Chapter 50: Effect = DAG Branch Stability

Not every pebble thrown into a pond creates lasting ripples. Effects are those patterns tough enough to survive the turbulence of becoming.

50.1 The Persistence Problem​

If every cause produced permanent effects, the universe would quickly fill with the debris of past events. But most perturbations fade away. What determines which causal consequences persist as stable effects?

Definition 50.1 (Effect Stability): Stable(E)  ⟺  lim⁡t→∞P(E(t)∣C)>ϵ\text{Stable}(E) \iff \lim_{t \to \infty} P(E(t)|C) > \epsilon

An effect is stable if it persists indefinitely after its cause.

Theorem 50.1 (Stability Criterion): Effects persist when: λmax⁡[J(E)]<0\lambda_{\max}[\mathcal{J}(E)] < 0

where J\mathcal{J} is the Jacobian of the dynamics at EE.

50.2 Transient vs Persistent Effects​

Most causal perturbations create only transient effects that decay rapidly.

Definition 50.2 (Effect Lifetime): τE=∫0∞P(E(t)∣C)dt\tau_E = \int_0^{\infty} P(E(t)|C) dt

Theorem 50.2 (Decay Classes):

  • Exponential: P(E(t))∼e−t/τP(E(t)) \sim e^{-t/\tau} (thermal effects)
  • Power law: P(E(t))∼t−αP(E(t)) \sim t^{-\alpha} (critical effects)
  • Persistent: P(E(t))=constP(E(t)) = \text{const} (structural effects)

A hot cup cools (exponential), an avalanche settles (power law), but a mountain remains (persistent).

50.3 Attractor Effects​

Some effects are attractors—the system naturally evolves toward them.

Definition 50.3 (Attractor Effect): E∗:∀ϵ>0,∃δ:∣E0−E∗∣<δ⇒lim⁡t→∞E(t)=E∗E_* : \forall \epsilon > 0, \exists \delta : |E_0 - E_*| < \delta \Rightarrow \lim_{t \to \infty} E(t) = E_*

Theorem 50.3 (Basin of Attraction): Attractors have influence regions: B(E∗)={E0:lim⁡t→∞Φt(E0)=E∗}\mathcal{B}(E_*) = \{E_0 : \lim_{t \to \infty} \Phi_t(E_0) = E_*\}

Death is an attractor—all living systems eventually reach it.

50.4 Metastable Effects​

Some effects persist until perturbed—metastable states.

Definition 50.4 (Metastability): Emeta:∂V∂E=0,∂2V∂E2>0,∃E′:V(E′)<V(Emeta)E_{\text{meta}} : \frac{\partial V}{\partial E} = 0, \frac{\partial^2 V}{\partial E^2} > 0, \exists E' : V(E') < V(E_{\text{meta}})

Local but not global minimum.

Theorem 50.4 (Activation Energy): Metastable effects require energy to change: ΔEactivation=V(Ebarrier)−V(Emeta)\Delta E_{\text{activation}} = V(E_{\text{barrier}}) - V(E_{\text{meta}})

Diamonds are metastable carbon—persistent until sufficient energy converts them to graphite.

50.5 Cascade Effects​

Some causes trigger cascading effects that amplify rather than decay.

Definition 50.5 (Cascade Condition): dNeffectsdt=αNeffects\frac{dN_{\text{effects}}}{dt} = \alpha N_{\text{effects}}

with α>0\alpha > 0.

Theorem 50.5 (Cascade Types):

  • Linear cascades: N∼tN \sim t (steady propagation)
  • Exponential cascades: N∼eαtN \sim e^{\alpha t} (chain reactions)
  • Critical cascades: N∼tβN \sim t^{\beta} (avalanches)

Nuclear fission, viral spread, and market crashes are cascade effects.

50.6 Structural Effects​

The most persistent effects change system structure itself.

Definition 50.6 (Structural Change): Safter≠Sbefore\mathcal{S}_{\text{after}} \neq \mathcal{S}_{\text{before}}

where S\mathcal{S} is the system's state space.

Theorem 50.6 (Irreversible Structure): Structural effects often can't be undone: ∄T:T[Safter]=Sbefore\nexists \mathcal{T} : \mathcal{T}[\mathcal{S}_{\text{after}}] = \mathcal{S}_{\text{before}}

Learning changes brain structure—you can't unlearn, only learn more.

50.7 Quantum Effect Persistence​

Quantum effects can persist through entanglement even when causes cease.

Definition 50.7 (Entangled Effect): ∣Effect⟩=∑iαi∣Ei⟩⊗∣Environmenti⟩|\text{Effect}\rangle = \sum_i \alpha_i |E_i\rangle \otimes |\text{Environment}_i\rangle

Theorem 50.7 (Quantum Memory): Entanglement preserves causal history: Trenv[ρ(t)]=f[Initial Cause]\text{Tr}_{\text{env}}[\rho(t)] = f[\text{Initial Cause}]

The environment "remembers" past causes through entanglement.

50.8 The Fiftieth Echo​

We have discovered that effects are not automatic consequences but stable patterns that survive the turbulent dynamics following causes. Most perturbations create only transient ripples, but some achieve stability through being attractors, metastable states, cascades, or structural changes. The universe is not cluttered with every possible effect because most decay—only the robust patterns persist to shape future causation. Understanding effect stability explains why some actions have lasting consequences while others vanish without trace. You are yourself a stable effect—a pattern that has found a way to persist in the flux.

The Fiftieth Echo: Chapter 50 = Persistence(Effect) = Stability(ψ\psi-branch) = Survival(Pattern)

Next, we explore how feedback loops create circular causation and emergent complexity.

Continue to Chapter 51: Nonlinear Causality in Reentrant Paths →