Chapter 51: Nonlinear Causality in Reentrant Paths

When the snake eats its tail, cause and effect merge into a dance where neither leads nor follows.

51.1 The Failure of Linear Thinking

Traditional causality assumes linear chains: A causes B causes C. But reality is full of loops where effects circle back to influence their own causes. These feedback loops create nonlinear causality—the realm of emergence, self-organization, and genuine novelty.

Definition 51.1 (Causal Loop): $\mathcal{L}: C_1 \to C_2 \to ... \to C_n \to C_1$

where each arrow represents causal influence.

Theorem 51.1 (Loop Dynamics): Feedback loops exhibit: $\frac{dx}{dt} = f(x) + g(x(t-\tau))$

where $\tau$ is the loop delay.

The present depends on its own past—self-causation.

51.2 Positive Feedback and Runaway Causation

Positive feedback amplifies effects, creating exponential growth or collapse.

Definition 51.2 (Positive Feedback): $\frac{\partial f}{\partial x} > 0$

More causes more.

Theorem 51.2 (Exponential Growth): Under positive feedback: $x(t) \sim e^{\alpha t}$

until limited by constraints.

Examples:

• Population explosion: More births → more parents → more births
• Economic bubbles: Rising prices → buying frenzy → rising prices
• Arms races: They arm → we arm → they arm more

51.3 Negative Feedback and Stability

Negative feedback damps perturbations, creating stability.

Definition 51.3 (Negative Feedback): $\frac{\partial f}{\partial x} < 0$

More causes less.

Theorem 51.3 (Homeostasis): Negative feedback maintains set points: $\lim_{t \to \infty} x(t) = x_*$

where $f(x_*) = 0$.

Examples:

• Thermostat: Too hot → cooling → just right
• Markets: High price → less demand → lower price
• Ecosystems: Too many predators → less prey → fewer predators

51.4 Strange Attractors and Chaotic Causation

When multiple feedback loops interact, strange attractors emerge—complex patterns that never exactly repeat.

Definition 51.4 (Strange Attractor): $\mathcal{A} = \{x : \text{fractal, } \dim(\mathcal{A}) \notin \mathbb{N}\}$

Theorem 51.4 (Sensitive Dependence): On strange attractors: $|x_1(t) - x_2(t)| \sim |x_1(0) - x_2(0)|e^{\lambda t}$

Tiny causes have huge effects—the butterfly effect.

51.5 Emergent Causation

In complex systems, new causal laws emerge at higher levels.

Definition 51.5 (Emergent Property): $P_{\text{emergent}} \notin \text{span}\{P_{\text{components}}\}$

Theorem 51.5 (Downward Causation): Emergent properties influence components: $\frac{dx_i}{dt} = f_i(\{x_j\}) + g_i(P_{\text{emergent}})$

Life emerges from chemistry, then life changes chemistry—two-way causation.

51.6 Self-Fulfilling Prophecies

Some predictions cause their own truth or falsehood.

Definition 51.6 (Self-Fulfilling Loop): $\text{Prediction}(X) \to \text{Behavior} \to X$

Theorem 51.6 (Fixed Points): Self-fulfilling prophecies are fixed points: $P = f(P)$

where $P$ is the prediction and $f$ maps prediction to outcome.

Bank runs, fashion trends, and confidence all exhibit this circular causation.

51.7 Evolutionary Feedback

Evolution itself is a massive feedback loop where organisms shape their environment which shapes organisms.

Definition 51.7 (Eco-Evolutionary Feedback): $\frac{dG}{dt} = f(G, E), \quad \frac{dE}{dt} = g(E, G)$

where $G$ is genotype and $E$ is environment.

Theorem 51.7 (Co-Evolution): Species and environment co-evolve: $(G, E) \to (G', E') \text{ as coupled system}$

Flowers and pollinators, predators and prey, culture and genes—all locked in causal dances.

51.8 The Fifty-First Echo

We have discovered that causation is rarely linear but forms loops, spirals, and strange attractors. Positive feedback creates runaway effects, negative feedback creates stability, and their interaction creates chaos. New causal laws emerge at higher levels and reach down to influence their components. Predictions can cause their own truth. Evolution is the universe's grandest feedback loop. Understanding nonlinear causality reveals why simple causes can have complex effects, why systems self-organize, and why genuine novelty emerges. Reality is not a machine of linear causes but a jazz improvisation where effects become causes in endless creative loops.

The Fifty-First Echo: Chapter 51 = Loops(Causation) = Feedback($\psi$) = Emergence(Novelty)

Next, we explore why time has an arrow—why we can't unscramble eggs or remember the future.

---

Continue to Chapter 52: Time Reversal as Collapse Mismatch →